DKOldies Lawsuit

If you are a fan of retro gaming, you may have heard of DKOldies, an online-only retailer that sells a wide range of vintage games and consoles. You may also have heard of the controversy surrounding the company pricing and business practices, which have led to a class action lawsuit from unhappy customers. In this article, we will explain what the DKOldies lawsuit is all about, why it matters for the retro gaming market, and what you can do to protect your rights and interests as a consumer.

Background on DKOldies

DKOldies is a Pennsylvania-based company that was founded in 2003 by Drew Steimel. According to its website, DKOldies is “one of the largest retro video game companies in the world” and has “over 100,000 games, systems, and accessories in stock”. The company claims to offer “the best prices, quality, and service” and to have “a passion for the history, artwork, and stories of video games”.

However, not everyone is satisfied with DKOldies’ products and services. In recent years, the company has faced criticism from retro game collectors and enthusiasts for its allegedly deceptive and unfair practices, such as selling refurbished consoles as new, inflating prices well above market value, and providing false or misleading information to customers. Some of these complaints have been documented on social media platforms like TikTok, YouTube, and Reddit, where users have shared their negative experiences and exposed the company questionable tactics.

Details of the Lawsuit

In April 2023, a class action lawsuit was filed against DKOldies by Treehouse Law, a consumer protection law firm based in California. The lawsuit accuses DKOldies of violating several federal and state laws, including the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, the Unfair Competition Law, the False Advertising Law, and the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act. The lawsuit also alleges that DKOldies engaged in fraud, breach of contract, breach of warranty, and unjust enrichment.

The lawsuit claims that DKOldies sold refurbished consoles as new or factory sealed, without disclosing that they had been opened, repaired, or modified. The lawsuit also claims that DKOldies sold vintage games that were not authentic, but rather reproductions, bootlegs, or counterfeits. Furthermore, the lawsuit claims that DKOldies artificially inflated its prices by using deceptive strategies, such as creating fake scarcity, manipulating reviews, and using bots to bid on its own auctions. The lawsuit also claims that DKOldies provided false or misleading information to customers, such as misrepresenting the condition, rarity, or value of its products, or omitting important details or disclaimers.

The lawsuit seeks to represent a class of all consumers who purchased products from DKOldies since April 2019. The lawsuit demands that DKOldies stop its unlawful practices, provide full refunds or replacements to affected customers, and pay damages, attorney fees, and costs.

Current Legal Proceedings

As of November 2023, the lawsuit is still in its early stages. The parties are currently engaged in pre-trial motions, discovery processes, and hearings. DKOldies has denied the allegations and filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit, arguing that it has not violated any laws or harmed any customers. Treehouse Law has opposed the motion and filed a motion to certify the class, arguing that there are common issues and claims among the customers. The court has not yet ruled on these motions.

The lawsuit has also attracted the attention of other consumers who have joined the class or expressed their support. According to Treehouse Law, more than 10,000 customers have contacted the firm to share their stories or request more information. The firm has also created a website,, where customers can sign up for updates, submit evidence, or ask questions.

Implications for the Retro Gaming Industry

The DKOldies lawsuit could have significant implications for the retro gaming industry, as it could expose the problems and challenges that plague the market. Retro game collecting has become a popular and lucrative hobby, especially during the pandemic, as people seek nostalgia, entertainment, and investment opportunities. However, the market is also rife with issues, such as scarcity, price gouging, fraud, and lack of regulation. The lawsuit could shed light on these issues and prompt more scrutiny and accountability from the industry players.

The lawsuit could also shape the future of retro game collecting, as it could lead to more regulations and authentication requirements. Retro game collectors face a lot of uncertainty and risk when buying online, as they have to rely on the seller honesty and reputation. The lawsuit could highlight the need for more transparency and verification in the market, such as standardized grading systems, certification programs, or third-party appraisals. The lawsuit could also encourage more consumer education and awareness, as collectors need to be more informed and vigilant about the products they buy and the sources they trust.

Consumer Rights and Protections

As a consumer, you have certain rights and protections when buying products online, especially retro games and consoles. You have the right to receive accurate and complete information about the products you buy, such as their condition, origin, and value. You have the right to receive products that match the description and quality advertised by the seller. You have the right to receive products that are authentic, original, and functional, unless otherwise stated by the seller. You also have the right to receive products that are free from defects, damages, or tampering, unless otherwise stated by the seller.

If you believe that you have been deceived, misled, or harmed by a seller, you have the right to seek recourse and remedy. You can contact the seller directly and request a refund, exchange, or repair. You can also contact the platform or service that facilitated the transaction, such as eBay, PayPal, or Amazon, and file a complaint or dispute. You can also contact your credit card company or bank and request a chargeback or reversal. You can also contact a consumer protection agency, such as the Federal Trade Commission, the Better Business Bureau, or your state attorney general, and file a report or complaint. You can also contact a lawyer and pursue legal action, such as joining a class action lawsuit or filing an individual lawsuit.

As a consumer, you also have the responsibility to protect yourself and your interests when buying products online, especially retro games and consoles. You should do your research and due diligence before making a purchase, such as checking the seller reputation, feedback, and policies. You should also compare prices and values across different sources, such as PriceCharting, GameValueNow, or eBay. You should also inspect the products carefully and look for signs of authenticity, such as labels, serial numbers, or holograms. You should also test the products and verify their functionality, compatibility, and performance. You should also keep records and receipts of your transactions, such as invoices, tracking numbers, or confirmation emails.

Also Read: Exploring the C.W. Park USC Lawsuit: Insights and Implications for Academic Institutions

Expert Opinions and Community Reactions

The DKOldies lawsuit has sparked a lot of interest and discussion among experts and the retro gaming community. Some experts have weighed in on the legal complexities and potential outcomes of the lawsuit, such as the challenges of proving fraud, the difficulties of defining authenticity, and the implications of class action status. Some experts have also offered advice and tips for retro game collectors, such as how to spot fakes, how to avoid scams, and how to join the lawsuit.

The retro gaming community has also reacted to the lawsuit, with mixed opinions and emotions. Some collectors have expressed anger and frustration with DKOldies, accusing the company of ripping off customers, ruining the market, and tarnishing the hobby. Some collectors have also expressed support and solidarity with the plaintiffs, praising them for taking action, exposing the truth, and seeking justice. Some collectors have also expressed skepticism and indifference with the lawsuit, questioning its validity, relevance, or impact. Some collectors have also expressed curiosity and interest with the lawsuit, following its developments, sharing their experiences, or joining the class.


What are the specific criteria for joining the class action lawsuit against DKOldies?

A: To join the class action lawsuit against DKOldies, consumers would typically need to demonstrate that they purchased products from the company within the specified timeframe mentioned in the lawsuit, in this case, since April 2019. They would need to show proof of purchase and may need to demonstrate that they experienced the alleged deceptive practices or were affected by the issues outlined in the lawsuit. The specific steps would likely involve contacting the law firm handling the case, providing the necessary documentation, and following their guidance to become part of the class action.

What are the common signs of counterfeit or inauthentic vintage games that consumers should be aware of?

A: Identifying counterfeit or inauthentic vintage games can be challenging, but there are several indicators that consumers can look for. These include discrepancies in labeling, packaging, and overall presentation compared to authentic versions. For cartridges, differences in weight, color, and label quality can be telltale signs. Serial numbers and manufacturer marks can also be checked against known authentic examples. In some cases, the gameplay experience itself might reveal inauthenticity through glitches or deviations from the original game performance.

What kind of regulations or authentication requirements could potentially be introduced to the retro gaming market as a result of this lawsuit?

A: As for potential new regulations or authentication requirements that could arise from the DKOldies lawsuit, these could include industry-wide standards for verifying the authenticity of vintage games, possibly through third-party authentication services. There might also be more stringent requirements for sellers to disclose the condition and origin of the games they sell, ensuring consumers are fully informed. Such measures could help to increase transparency in the retro gaming market, giving consumers a clearer understanding of what they are purchasing and reducing the prevalence of counterfeit or misleadingly advertised products.


The DKOldies lawsuit is a significant and controversial event in the retro gaming industry, as it raises important questions and issues about the market, the products, and the consumers. The lawsuit could have a lasting impact on the future of retro game collecting, as it could lead to more regulations, authentication, and education. The lawsuit could also have a personal impact on you, as a retro game collector, as it could affect your rights, interests, and choices. As the lawsuit progresses, you should stay informed and proactive, and protect yourself and your collection. You should also keep enjoying and celebrating the history, artwork, and stories of video games.

By John Smith

Hi, I'm John Smith, a freelance writer and blogger from Omaha, Nebraska. I love sharing my thoughts and opinions on various topics, such as Tech, sports, entertainment, and more. I started this blog in 2023 to express myself and connect with other like-minded people. I hope you enjoy reading my posts and feel free to leave your comments and feedback. Thank you for visiting my website!